We hear it a lot. We say it a lot. “All sins are the same.” But is that statement biblically accurate? Throughout history, mankind has naturally recognized some sins, some acts to be more evil than others. But why?
Some crimes result in greater harm than others. The impact is deeper and life-altering, like the devastation caused by child abuse or human trafficking. Sometimes the crime greatly affects many people, like the genocide of six million Jews by Adolf Hitler or the mass shooting at Columbine High School. Human authorities recognize these “worse” crimes by inflicting greater punishment.
But what about God? Does He distinguish between different types of sin? For instance, is shoplifting a candy bar as bad in God’s eyes as murder? The answer is both yes and no.
All Sins are the Same in that they All Bring Spiritual Death
To determine our legal standing before God, the Bible breaks everyone into two classifications: Lawbreakers and law keepers. For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it. For he who said, “Do not commit adultery,” also said, “Do not murder.” If you do not commit adultery but do murder, you have become a transgressor of the law (James 2:10-11, ESV). Breaking God’s law on any point, no matter how small, makes someone a lawbreaker. So, you can imagine that the “law keeper” group is pretty small. As in zero.
The Bible teaches – and life confirms – that all people have sinned. We are all law breakers. For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23, ESV). The Greek word translated as “sin” in Romans 3:23 means to miss the mark or deviate from the target. The target we’ve missed is God’s holy transcendence. No one can measure up, no matter how “good” we are. Not a murderer or a shoplifter. Not a prideful person or a worrier. We’ve all fallen short of God’s glorious perfection.
All sinners have also earned the same wage” or cost for our sin. For the wages of sin is death, but the free gift of God is eternal life in Christ Jesus our Lord (Romans 6:23, ESV). One sin, no matter how small makes us a sinner, legally guilty before a holy God and deserving of death. All sinners – no matter the sin – are separated from God and the spiritual life He gives. Every single one of us has earned a one-way ticket to eternal punishment – unless we receive God’s free gift of eternal salvation through Jesus. (Find out more about How to Have a Saving Relationship with Jesus.).
Not all Sins in the Bible Received the Same Punishment
Although any and all sin brings spiritual death, God does not feel the same way about all sin. Yes, He hates all sin. But, some sin He hates more than others. The Old Testament law demonstrates this truth by assigning different levels of punishment to different kinds of sin.
First, the Old Testament Law made distinction between sins based on the level of intent of the sinner.
God forgave the “unintentional” or “unwitting” sin of a remorseful sinner who brought a sin offering. (See Leviticus 4:1-26 and Numbers 15:27-31.) But the defiant sinner would not be forgiven. They were to be cut off from God’s community (Numbers 15:30-31). God views some sins as more rebellious than others. Some were committed out of ignorance of God’s expectations. Other sinners well knew God’s requirements and chose to blatantly disregard them, defying God’s authority.
The Old Testament Law also determined varying degrees of punishment for sin based on the severity of the impact it had on others and how much the sin maligned the name of God. For instance, a thief had to pay restitution; someone involved with the occult had to leave the community of Israel; and some sexual sins and dishonoring parents earned the death penalty. (See Exodus 22 and Leviticus 20 for the specifics on these examples.)
What about Sin in the New Testament?
You may be thinking: “Well, that was the Old Testament; things changed with Jesus.” But, distinction between sin also fills the New Testament – including the teachings of Jesus. Again, any and all sin brings spiritual death, but the New Testament emphasizes a priority of God’s commands, levels of severity, degrees of punishment, and intensity of God’s displeasure toward various sins.
Jesus clearly indicated that some of God’s commands are more important than others. For instance, Jesus called the Jewish leaders hypocrites for their detailed attention to tithing while neglecting “the weightier matters of the law: justice and mercy and faithfulness” (Matthew 23:23, ESV). While God calls us to support His church and ministers, He is more concerned about our character and treatment of others.
We see this same principle in a conversation between Jesus and a Jewish scribe. When the scribe asked Jesus which commandment is the most important, Jesus gave an answer. “The most important is, ‘Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one. And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength.’ The second is this: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ There is no other commandment greater than these” (Mark 12:28b-31). God prioritizes how we respond to Him and how we treat others over His other commands.
Jesus also considered some sins to be more serious than others. For instance, in referring to sin in two individuals’ lives, He described one a “speck” and the other a “plank” (Matthew 7:3-5). Although Jesus didn’t explain the reason for the difference in His classification, He did give clearer insight in other passages. Jesus distinguished between sins in three areas.
Three Areas of Distinction among Sins
- Greater harm – Some sins cause greater levels of spiritual and physical harm than others. Jesus repeatedly gave strong warnings against harming others. For instance, He condemned the Pharisees for taking advantage of marginalized people like widows (Luke 20:45-47) and He warned of great punishment for anyone who causes someone else to sin (Mark 9:42). The mishandling of God’s Word is also a sin that causes great spiritual harm to others. Peter wrote that false teachers will bring “swift punishment” on themselves (2 Peter 2:1). And James, wrote that those who teach God’s Word will be “judged more strictly” (James 3:1).”
- Greater knowledge – Jesus taught that greater knowledge incurs greater punishment. Those who know more of God’s expectations yet sins will be judged more severely than those who don’t know God’s expectations and commit the same sin (Luke 12:42-48). The more we know about God, the more we are responsible to
- Greater dishonor – When Jesus stood trial before Pilate, He declared that the one who had handed Him over had committed a greater sin than Pilate who confirmed His death sentence (John 19:11). Whether Jesus meant the betrayer Judas or the Jewish high priest, this guilty one blatantly rejected Jesus and submitted Him to great ridicule. Like this rejection, some sin causes more harm to the name of Christ. Any blatant, unrepentant sin dishonors God’s name and harms the fellowship of the church (1 Corinthians 5:1-13, 6:9-10). Sexual sin also uniquely dishonors God. Because the Holy Spirit lives within believers, anytime a Christian commits sexual immorality her or she defiles the special intimacy we share with God (1 Corinthians 6:12-20).
Yes, the Bible does indicate that God distinguishes between severity of sin. For unbelievers, greater sin will result in a greater level of eternal punishment (Luke 10:13-14). For believers, sinning after salvation will not keep us out of heaven, but our level of obedience will impact our eternal rewards (1 Corinthians 3:8-15). But for those in a saving relationship with Jesus, our God is faithful to forgive our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness! (See 1 John 1:9)
Are these new thoughts for you? When you study the Bible, how can you set aside preconceived ideas so God can show you truths from His Word?
Sign up to get Kathy's blog posts by email and get a free Bible study on the book of Titus.
Wow, Kathy. What a weighty discussion. I love being challenged to think differently or more deeply. Thank you for analyzing this topic from all sides.
So good!!!!! In fact, we were just talking, as a family last night (my pastor grandson, wife and 5 gt. grands) about Rahab’s lie to give protection. Was it wrong and a sin since it was a lie ?? This us so timely!! I will share it!! Also, the idea of sexual sin with the Holy Spirit within!!!! Wow! Have never read, hard or thought about that fact! That reality really makes that immense. I will share that, as well!! Thanks, Kathy, as always, for your study, insight and sharing!! Love and prayers, Dee
Thank you, Kathy, for this much-needed teaching.
One thing I remember all sin is a sin against God. When people unintentionally sin there was a city of refuge to run to. Now as believers, Jesus is our refuge.